June 21, 2014
![]() |
| Can You search my phone after arrest in DC |
So you are stopped and arrested - for the purpose of this conversation lets say for possession of marijuana (I know almost legal but still not in DC). The police arrest you for the simple possession of marijuana - can they now search your iphone. On the iphone you have some incriminating information (besides nude photos of your girlfriend) - Can the police search your phone?
It is settled law throughout the country that a custodial arrest based on probable cause justifies a full search of an arrestee. The United States Supreme Court ruled in Chimel v. California, that if police arrest you without a search warrant the police may search the body of the person and “the area into which he might reach,” This legal doctrine has been referred to as “search incident to arrest." The full search of the arrestee may include wallet and/or other documents that are on the individual. Furthermore, the Court has ruled in United States v. Edwards, 415 U.S. 800 (1974), that the police may search any items found on the person of an arrestee so long as the search is not conducted in an unreasonable manner. The court had little problem making the decision because the items was physically on the person.
Along comes the smart phone. The age of information where everything is on a smart phone. You are literally walking around with a device that may have your life story in it. The age of the smart phone. A smart phone which is basically a phone that has applications to make life easier, Internet access, voice service,text messaging, e-mail, pictures and possible the most private information of an individual. So now the question becomes can the cell phone be searched (and by searched I mean go through numbers, pictures, searches you did etc) if the police had probable cause to arrest in the District of Columbia.
Now let me say this before I give you my opinion of whether the phone can be searched without a warrant - The law is about to change because the United States Supreme Case has taken up the case of in United States v. Wurie as well Riley v. California. Both cases deal with this issue head on and the United States Supreme Court may have an answer shortly. However, in the District of Columbia U.S. v. Scott, 987 A.2d 1180 (DC, 2010) states that Probable cause to search a particular place exists "where the known facts and circumstances are sufficient to warrant a man of reasonable prudence in the belief that contraband or evidence of a crime will be found" In our case the facts I am suggesting is that the phone is recovered after a probable cause for an arrest for some crime. The test is an objective one: whether the "historical facts, viewed from the standpoint of an objectively reasonable police officer, amount to probable cause. The search of the phone clearly would require the officer to have some particularized information on the phone that there is crime material on there. So A long story short - Police should not be able to search the contents of the phone without a warrant in the District of Columbia under "search incident to arrest" theory.

No comments:
Post a Comment